(Op-ed) Chris Friel
19 Jun 2022, 06:53 GMT+10
The Ukrainian banker had taken part in the first round of negotiations between Russia and Ukraine on February 28. They were held in Gomel, Belarus, and Kireev was photographed sitting next to Tatar politician Rustem Umerov for the Ukrainians. The second round took place on March 3 in Brest, also in Belarus. Kireev was absent for these and, though scheduled to attend, Umerov was not photographed at the talks either, at least when they began at 3pm.
Two days later Kireev was shot in the head by the Ukrainians outside the Pechersk Court in Kyiv. The narrative of his death is contested. It was said that Kireev was executed as a Russian spy, that he was shot resisting arrest, and finally that he had died on a special mission. This last position was put out on Ukraine's Facebook page in the evening of March 5 and repeated by two sources linked to Bellingcat. First Bellingcat's Latvian partner The Insider explained that he had died "while performing a special task," and a little later Bellingcat's Executive Director tweeted the same. Christo Grozev was the only person to provide the link to Facebook and, as a conversation with the editor of Meduza shows, he had been attentive to the news that morning from pro-Russian sources saying the Ukrainians had gone on the rampage.
The next twist in what we might call the exculpatory narrative emerged on Monday March 28, at around 7am in the morning (UK time). Proekt Media was reporting that Abramovich was due to participate in a further round of talks in Turkey along with Umerov and made the observation that talking could be as dangerous as fighting. Apparently well-informed, Proekt explained that Kireev's death was a mix-up, and then dropped the bombshell that Umerov had been poisoned in early March. Umerov declined to comment, but sent out a warning about the fake news that was repeated by The Insider, also that morning, when without demur it referenced the news.
One killed. One poisoned. No Bellingcat.
Hitherto, not a scintilla of evidence had hinted that Abramovich was anywhere near Kyiv in early March, but that afternoon Bellingcat confirmed the WSJ's scoop that he had both participated in the talks and had been poisoned at them. He was one of three who suffered symptoms after having taken part in informal negotiations twenty-five days earlier, along with Umerov and an unnamed Russian businessman.
Bellingcat were directly involved, apparently, as on the day after the poisoning Grozev had been called upon by the victims to arrange some tests by two chemical weapons experts and a medical doctor. At any rate, only someone with first-hand knowledge could release the central piece of the jigsaw tweeted at 4.50pm:
"The three men experiencing the symptoms consumed only chocolate and water in the hours before the symptoms appeared. A fourth member of the team who also consumed these did not experience symptoms."
"Exhibit A" points in one direction only: the fourth man was the poisoner. Later that evening Grozev explained that because all four had shared the same environment the symptoms could not be dismissed as an allergy and he contended that the non-fatal dosage must have been a warning sign lest Abramovich become too much of an "honest broker" at the talks. But if it was something they all consumed, how come the fourth man wasn't affected? Though never said, the idea was that he could control what the others should eat even as he knew what not to eat.
All we know about the fourth man is that he was part of the Ukrainian negotiating team, the informal one supposedly meeting in Kyiv rather than the verifiable talks that we know took place in Brest along with seven suited Russians. Eliminating those, it's very difficult to suspect anyone else. "Exhibit A" must be seen as yet another step in the exculpatory narrative. Kireev's death was a mistake, and besides, he was a poisoner.
A conspiracy theory? But if Abramovich was poisoned someone must have committed the crime. The only evidence we have is from Bellingcat, and given that they examined him they would know who the fourth man was, what he ate, and that he never got ill. So who was he? Ironically, at the precise moment that Bellingcat say they were arranging the examination of the victims they tweeted:
"Bellingcat will make available all information we're collecting, verifying, and archiving to this process and any other accountability process that requests information from us."
So why the silence? Confidentiality can't be the issue as Kireev is dead. Indeed, if he was the fourth man Bellingcat's experts were among the last to see him alive.
Bellingcat needs to tell us all about Kireev.
(The writer Doctor Chris Friel taught maths for many years before undertaking, first, a masters in Philosophy, and second, doctoral research on value and credibility in the thought of Bernard Lonergan. In 2018 he investigated at length the "purposely timed hysteria" of the pro-Israel hawks in the UK amidst the antisemitism crisis, and commencing in 2019 has devoted an equally lengthy exploration of the Cardinal George Pell case and its context).
Get a daily dose of Russia Herald news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Russia Herald.
More InformationWASHINGTON D.C.: In a cardboard box factory outside Baltimore, people have been walking into the office of Paul Centenari, chief ...
DELFT, Netherlands: IKEA officials said this week that the furniture retailer's warehouses in Europe are as full as they were ...
NEW YORK CITY, New York: After the first six months of 2022, the S&P 500 recorded a loss of 20.6 ...
WASHINGTON D.C.: Due to the record high trade deficit and a resurgence in COVID-19 infections that curbed spending on services, ...
TAIPEI, Taiwan: The world's fourth largest chip designer by revenue, Taiwan's MediaTek, has told Reuters that it plans to create ...
NEW YORK, New York - U.S. stocks rebounded on Friday, a day after major across-the-board sell-offs."Consensus estimates for 2022 and ...
DUBAI, UAE: The Arab states have built significant amounts of solar and wind power installations, and are in line to ...
ASSAM, India: During this week's heavy rains, which caused the region's worst floods in years, staff at the Cachar Cancer ...
KAREN STATE, Myanmar - Over the past three days, an army outpost meters away from Myanmar's border with Thailand has ...
BERLIN, Germany: A German Interior Ministry spokesperson has said that in a bid to relieve airports overwhelmed by staff shortages ...
WATFORD, UK: Watford F.C. has cancelled a friendly match against the Qatar national team due to the Gulf country's human ...
JAKARTA, Indonesia: Indonesian President Joko Widodo has said that he will urge his Russian and Ukrainian counterparts to open peace ...